When I lost my job, my sister said not to worry about rent. Now, she wants me to pay her $5,000 or we're done. What do I do?

Dear For Love & Money,

Last year, I lost my job and moved in with my older sister. She offered her guest room and said not to worry about rent until I got back on my feet. I now have a stable job, and for the last five months, I've been paying her $600/month and helping with groceries and pet care.

Now she's demanding I "repay" the eight months I lived there rent-free to the tune of nearly $5,000. She even made a spreadsheet and accused me of hiding money when she found out I've been saving for a down payment on a condo. I offered her $1,000 as a gesture of thanks, but she called it insulting and said if I don't pay in full, we're "done."

I'm heartbroken. I thought I was being respectful and contributing what I could. She's making me feel like I'm selfish and ungrateful. Except I never agreed to back-pay anything. Should I stand my ground or pay to keep the peace?

Sincerely,

Feeling Used and Confused

Compare Today's Banking Offers

Dear Feeling Used,

The best thing about siblings is all that shared history. The worst thing about siblings is all that shared history. Our sibling bond hangs in the balance of this paradox — and it's as beautiful as it is tricky.

Let's start with the tricky bits. When you remember your big sister "babysitting" by shoving you in a closet, or your little brother wetting the bed you shared when Great Aunt Phyllis came to visit, well, that's what we call "baggage." It's hard not to cap our characterizations of siblings around the time we all moved out of the family home.

Make no mistake, this goes both ways. Your sister probably still sees you as the helpless little sibling she had to rescue time and time again. In her mind, she may even believe she practically raised you — older sisters often do. Meanwhile, you may remember her "raising" you as bossing you around when it was both unnecessary and unwelcome.

And yes, I do have two older sisters. How could you tell?

Another way sibling relationships can be unusually complicated is that they rarely follow the same rules of civility that govern the rest of our relationships. I see a lot of this in your letter. I don't know your sister, but I don't know many adults who would call a gesture of gratitude from someone they love "insulting" — except possibly my siblings. We grow up, we learn to treat people with a level of care and decorum that allows us to blend in and succeed in society. For many of us, however, this newfound maturity doesn't extend to our families. On one hand, this shows just how safe we feel within the intimacy of those relationships; on the other, it means we're treating the people we love most in the world the worst.

And we haven't even talked about sibling rivalry yet. Unless you're the eldest, you've most likely been fighting for your parents' attention since day one. That competition naturally spills over into other areas. One subtle but powerful way it shows up is through memory. Your sister may not remember things differently to be difficult; she probably genuinely has different recollections, shaped by her own experience, her role in the family, and her feelings about you. The truth is, all of us filter memories through the lens of our identities, and sibling rivalry often distorts the view.

Your story is laced with all these dynamics: old wounds driving new drama, the unique rudeness of family, the clashing versions of history.

But now let's talk about the good stuff.

The same shared history that causes so much friction also builds an incomparable closeness. You know your sister. You know how many times she's been there for you, like inviting you to live in her home indefinitely. But, of course, every time she helped you, she probably saw it through the lens of having to help the sibling who can't quite stand on their own. Even when the gesture came from love, part of her may have sighed in exasperation.

The roles we play in our families — helper, screwup, savior, rebel — are like shoes we outgrew long ago. Outdated, uncomfortable, and several sizes too small. My advice: Take off the shoes. You aren't the helpless sibling whose big eyes and quivering lip practically force your sister to step in to save you. Show her that.

Of course, her ultimatums, her imaginary contracts, and her condescending tone haven't been great. But you don't need to match her emotional chaos. Offer to pay her back, even if it has to be in installments. Be calm and clear. Don't let the conversation spiral into another argument fueled by old resentments.

Then, move out as soon as you can. And once you've repaid her, don't get financially entangled again. She's shown that she can't handle that part of your relationship without turning it into something toxic. It's not unforgivable, but it is something to learn from.

Finally, lean on the beautiful part of your shared history. The unbreakable bond that's forged when you bury the shards of your grandmother's vase together and swear to never tell another living soul. The bond that's only possible when you've witnessed another person's deepest secrets play out in real time and received their bad craft projects as birthday gifts. When you can complain about the same flawed parents. A bond that's forged only when you're at your very lowest point, and they let you move in.

You asked me whether you should stand your ground or pay to keep the peace. Let me answer your question with one of my own: If you woke up tomorrow and your sister was gone, how much would you pay to have her back for even one more day?

I bet it's more than $5,000.

Rooting for you,

For Love & Money

Looking for advice on how your savings, debt, or another financial challenge is affecting your relationships? Write to For Love & Money using this Google form.

Olivia Christensen

Olivia Christensen is a freelance writer whose work has been featured in outlets including Romper and Parents magazine. She lives outside Kansas City with her husband and three children, and when she isn't using her keyboard to share her opinions, she's probably hiking. 

Read more Read less